Saturday, August 29, 2009

Question Stems Week 4 (2 for Dillard)--Comparison

How does Wiglaf compare to a younger Beowulf?

7 comments:

  1. wiglaf and the younger beowulf are quite similar. They both are fearless and strong. The only diference between the both would be experience. Overall they are the same in every other area. Both were good soldiers and would do whatever to protect their ruler and the people that follow them.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Jacob Saunders- Wiglaf was not only a strong man, but he was extremely fearless and loyal. Just as Beowulf was loyal to his king, to the extent that he fought Grendel without weapons to maintain his honor in the king's sight, so was Wiglaf loyal to Beowulf, honoring him especially in his old age, by fighting alongside him and causing him to be able to see the hoarded treasures of the dragon stored up in the tower. Wiglaf considered his leader's state of vulnerability and put forth his best attempt to be his helper in his old age. Wiglaf was the only one of all of Beowulf's comrades that remained standing with him even under the greatest danger and intimidation, and for that he was rewarded with a place in the kingdom, even as Beowulf was.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Wiglaf could be seen as a Beowulf of the next generation by some, or at the very least someone of comparable bravery and strength. He is willing to serve Beowulf however he can, but is also aware of the need for more than one fighter on the front lines (which is something Beowulf might never have admitted to in his younger days in lieu of handling the problem himself). Nevertheless, his decision to fight alongside his king is admirable and very much a sign of his conviction - a trait he shares quite fully with Beowulf.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Wiglaf is the same as a young Beowulf only in the aspect of being fearless, committed, and a hero. He's fearless because he wasn't scared of facing an extravagant dragon with only one man by his side. His commitment/loyalty to Beowulf is like Beowulf's loyalty to Hrothgar and Herot, by getting rid of their demons in the lake. And lastly he wants to be a hero, saving his town from a fire breathing dragon.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Similarly to Beowulf, Wiglaf, he stepped up to the plate to fight for his kingdom. Doing so, he showed Beowulf that he was loyal to him unlike his other fellow followers who cowardly ran away to seek safety from the dragon. As a result of Wiglaf showing so much courage, he was honored to fight alongside Beowulf and was also rewarded for his actions. Maybe he may be provided with a higher ranking in the kingdom jus like Beowulf was.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Wiglaf is very similar to Beowulf. In fact, one could say that Wiglaf is Beowulf's successor. He exhibits the same strength that Beowulf had when he was younger when he helps him stand against the dragon. In doing so, he also showed tremendous courage incomparable to that of all of Beowulf's other men because Wiglaf was the only one to stay and help him fight. The theory that he is Beowulf's successor is that he was left alive when Beowulf left him his rings, helmet, and armor, and left him with the order to serve his people's needs.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Beowulf is brave and strong, filled with valor and a sense of duty. It can be said that Wilgaf could be the next generation Beowulf, as he too shares these traits. He is willing to fight alongside his king, and shows that he is quite admirable. Just as Beowulf would, Wiglaf would willingly fight againsts the greastest of odds, and in the face of danger. One could reveiw such details, placing Wiglaf in Beowulf's place in due time. It is his courage and commitment that makes Wiglaf, in his own way, much like Beowulf, during his springtime of youth.

    ReplyDelete